Natsu Banzuke Crystal Ball

How will these March rankings be reshuffled for May?

Do you want to know where your favorite rikishi is likely to be ranked for the Natsu basho without waiting for the official announcement on April 30? Never fear, the crystal ball is here. This time, I’ll give you my predicted banzuke right at the start, and then go through some of the biggest moves and uncertainties.

Haru winning records in green; losing records in red.

Biggest Rises

The biggest rise, 10 full ranks, belongs to Shimanoumi, who vaults all the way from Juryo 1 to Maegashira 8. After spending the better part of four years in upper Makushita and lower Juryo, Shimanoumi broke out with two consecutive 13-2 championships in the second division, and it will be interesting to see how he fares in his top-division debut. If my prediction is correct, he will be doing so at the highest rank in about a decade.

Other notable jumps belong to Ichinojo (M4 to Sekiwake), Aoiyama (M7 to Komusubi), Kotoshogiku (M8 to M1), Ryuden (M11 to M5), Yoshikaze (M12 to M6), and Chiyomaru (J1 to M12).

Biggest Falls

There are some doozies here. As you can see in my Juryo forecast, Chiyonokuni will fall from M12 into the bottom half of the second division, but this is due to injury, not performance. He’ll be joined there by M16 Yutakayama, whose drop is entirely due to performance. And Ikioi, who should have sat out the last tournament, will manage the rare feat of falling all the way from M9 to Juryo, becoming the highest-ranked rikishi to drop to the second division without sitting out since Toyohibiki three years ago.

Staying in Makuuchi but falling from the joi-jin into the bottom half of the division are Kaisei (M1 to M9), Nishikigi (M3 to M9), and Tochiozan (M4 to M12).

Best Banzuke Luck

Good banzuke luck refers to being either under-demoted or over-promoted given one’s rank and record as a consequence of other performances. In my forecast, such good luck is entirely concentrated at the bottom of the banzuke. Tokushoryu and Enho are very fortunate to be promoted from Juryo to Makuuchi at all, much less to be ranked M14, but the losing records by everyone ranked M14-M17 at Haru make it pretty much impossible to do anything else. And among that make-koshi crowd, Ishiura and Chiyoshoma are very lucky to cling to the bottom of the top division, and Terutsuyoshi would be ranked lower except for the fact that there’s no one to move ahead of him.

Worst Banzuke Luck

Actually, no ranking in my forecast is unreasonably harsh. The only rikishi with any right to complain are Onosho and Shohozan, and they only drop half a rank further than they “should.”

Biggest Question Marks

Let’s take it from the top of the banzuke.

  • Will Mitakeumi (7-8) get to stay at Komusubi with a half-rank demotion, or will that slot go to Kotoshogiku instead?
  • How far will Tamawashi (5-10) fall from West Sekiwake? Based on recent precedent for sanyaku rikishi, I’ve given him the mildest possible demotion, to M2e, but he could easily end up a rank lower.
  • How big will Shimanoumi’s promotion be? Ranking him at M8e seems pretty reasonable to me, but anywhere from M7e to M8w wouldn’t surprise me, and the banzuke committee could opt to go even lower.
  • How far will Kaisei and Nishikigi fall? I’ve given them relatively lenient demotions because of their places in the joi and the caliber of the opposition they faced, but one could easily argue for placing them a rank lower. The same can be said about Tochiozan, but it’s harder to see who could move ahead of him.
  • What will they do with the mess at the bottom of the banzuke? Having four exchanges between Makuuchi and Juryo makes the most sense to me, but anything from two (with Toyonoshima and Ikioi surviving) to five (with Takagenji trading places with Chiyoshoma) is possible. And when it comes to the precise rankings, any solution that avoids promoting someone with a losing record is a victory.

Tune in at the end of the month to find out how the crystal ball did!

20 thoughts on “Natsu Banzuke Crystal Ball

  1. I have Tamawashi, Kaisei and Nishikigi a rank lower and I have Takagenji replacing replacing Chiyoshoma. Strictly on my numbers I would have had Kotoshogiku taking the Kw slot but went with my gut (always a good sumo tactic) and let Mitakeumi hang on to the rank.

      • This will be a good test to see if they consider popularity in the rankings. I’ve seen some predictions that included Takagenji in Makuuchi, and I kind of interpreted them as wishful thinking. He is certainly a lot more popular than Chiyoshoma.

  2. And the question on all our minds: If Kotoshogiku gets promoted back into the San’yaku, will he start doing the backbend again?

  3. If Chiyoshoma remains in the top division, he’ll be the luckiest rikishi in decades. I can see that happening, though, considering what it took for Shimanoumi to get promoted. It’s more about a lack of quality Juryo records than anything else.

    • Yup, that would be two consecutive very lucky escapes for him, and this time he’d be going down for sure if there was another remotely plausible promotion candidate.

  4. I went with the same Juryo promotion scenario as you in the end. But equally give the general conservative approach with Juryo promotions I could see a scenario where Ikioi and Toyonoshima are saved

  5. What’s a probability that “mr. banzuke luck” Shodai will be promoted up a few ranks? 🙂 🙂

    For 2018 Hatsu Basho, he was M4. In 7 tournaments since then until 2019 Hatsu Basho, he had 5 make koshis and only 2 kachi koshis (all 6-9 to 9-6 range), still for the 2019 Haru Basho he was M3.

    Is this luck, or does he have a strong god father among the powers that be?

    V.

    • LOL. His rank over that time has generally been in line with my predictions, so I think it’s just normal banzuke luck. If he’s received favorable treatment, it’s only been by half a rank or so. And his 5-10 should definitely see him drop to mid-Makuuchi—if not, then we’ll have some evidence for the god father hypothesis 😉

  6. I think it will be 5 in and 5 out. Chiyoshoma, Yutakayama, Toyonoshima, Chiyonokuni, Ikioi out and Shimanoumi, Chiyomaru, Enho, Tokushoryu, Takagenji will be in.

  7. There sure are a lot of question marks making this one just as hard as some of the previous banzuke to predict. So many 7-8 wrestlers who precedent could have remaining where the are, dropping a half rank or a full rank. I’d be surprised if Tamawashi is higher than M3.

    • My general rule of thumb is to drop 7-8 rikishi one rank if that fits well with the rest of the banzuke, and otherwise half-a-rank unless there’s no reasonable alternative, in which case they stay where they are. In Tamawashi’s case, I’m following the precedent from last time when Myogiryu ended up ranked ahead of Nishikigi in a very similar scenario. But dropping him below Endo and Daieisho is a perfectly likely solution; I would only be surprised if he’s lower than M3e.

  8. I have to admit that I’m hardly a fan of Chiyoshoma (quite the opposite actually) but to me it doesn’t feel right for him to stay in makuuchi. If you score a losing record at the very last rank of the division there should be no alternative to demotion. Even with a “respectable” 7-8.

    • I agree, but who do you replace him with? It took Shimanoumi two consecutive 13-2 records to get promoted to the top division.

Comments:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.