With the tournament now complete, I am eager to see what becomes of Takakeisho. There was a thought at the beginning of all of this, that he might begin March as the second Yokozuna alongside Terunofuji. Most likely that would have been contingent on a strong performance and a yusho. Some readers have pointed out that at 12-3 yusho against a Maegashira 13 is not at all strong. They are correct, but allow me to present the case why he many get the rope anyhow
Merit – At the end of Hatsu, Takakeisho had earned his third yusho, he had also just had a yusho doten, and the jun-yusho in July of 2022. Is that Hakuho level? Of course not, but it’s pretty close to Kakuryu level. But looking across the landscape of ozumo right now, who else is dominant in any sort of consistent fashion? No one, that’s who. There was a time a few tournaments ago, where it looked like Wakatakakage was going to hit and sustain a higher level of dominance, but he has since receded closer to his averages. Which takes us to our next point.
Safety – The Sumo Kyokai has a kanban rikishi problem. They have a Yokozuna, for as long as they can keep him going. There are likely regular update from Isegahama on his status, and they are well aware how his recovery is going. For a time they thought they might mint a new Ozeki this basho, and it would solve a thorny issue for them. Right now, they need Takakeisho if they are going to uphold the tradition of having at minimum 2 Ozeki on the banzuke. It may seem odd to westerners, but the sumo world really does love their traditions. There is a risk that Takakeisho might become injured in training, or worse yet in a match, and be 2 tournaments away from following Mitakeumi and Shodai down the banzuke. With no successor yet apparent, they need to give themselves some time should that happen. So, make Takakeisho a Yokozuna, and he can be on the banzuke even if he is taking a few months off to recover from some injury. Problem solved. It could also bring some beneifts…
Support – Sumo is largely a Japanese sport made for Japanese speaking fans living in Japan. Those who know and love Japan, understand that having a Japanese yokozuna is a big deal for the popularity of the sport nationally. Minting a new Yokozuna would boost interest and visibility of the sport, as it increasingly competes for attention of fans in a crowded media market. Simply put, it may be worth some much needed cash to mint a Japanese Yokozuna right now.
So there are my three points, I think he’s earned it, it solves a problem with the banzuke until such time as one of the next generation can get their sumo together, and it will be good for business. Feel free to chime in in the comment section below.
UPDATE: The Yokozuna Deliberation Council has now met, and while some members felt there should have been a promotion discussion by the JSA (there wasn’t one), most members believed that it wasn’t a high-level yusho, so there wasn’t much to discuss. The run is on for Haru, with promotion conditions unspecified. -lksumo, via Kintamayama over on Sumo Forum.
42 thoughts on “The Case For Yokozuna Takakeisho”
The general overall standard of Sumo appears to me to be clearly dropping, so to promote Takakeisho against the backdrop of that environment would seem pointless. He has not yet earned the right to be Yokozuna with is lack of dominance.
There is no comparison necessary! Takakeisho is a proven Ozeki. He was consecutively at the top on the final day during the last two bashos. A play off is for the prize money has nothing to do with the strengthen of Takakeisho. Remember there was a Yokozuna who had never won any basho. Takakeisho deserves being promoted due to his powerful sumo and fulfiling the requirements.
Late to the party and the question is moot now, but I’ll say Takakeisho would easily be yokozuna material as a pure pusher-thruster if he were not so injury-prone. I believe all of his disappointing performances at ozeki have been due to injuries; he’s never seemed low on energy or mentally zoned out a là Goeido. He managed a beltless yori win against Mitakeumi in 2019 but injured himself doing it and has never tried it again. In this basho we’ve learned that his dropped bouts occurred after he picked up another injury. It’s so frustrating to watch, and I’m just a Takakeisho fan; it must be infinitely more frustrating for him.